Well, I will agree that a toggle linked and short stroked win/copy is smooth and sweet, I will stick with my marlins.
I never have problems, the stroke is short enough for me. I did a do it yourself action job and the one piece firing pin too. I am pretty much sold on them. Maybe it gets down to what you are used to. I will never figure out why they were not allowed in classic cowboy class. I would have shot that class, had they kept it to one sixgun and BP only, with a marlin and the SXS. That would have been plenty classic cowboy to me. Remember Marlins horse and rider ads? Well, as it is, here I am a senior and sticking it out in frontiersman, having retired the cartridge guns for this year. :-)