Time to get out the sandpaper. I use 120 grit, wet, on the soft part. Then start with 220 and work up to 500 or as shiny as I want on the hard part. The tip is to have it screwed onto the stock, and wrap a layer of electrical tape around the wood just up to the pad. That way you can butt the sandpaper up to the tape and not scratch the wood. Done right it looks like it grew there. After you're done, a light mist of WD-40 and wipe it off and it'll look nice.