Huntsman1 but I went with the 300gr SST's, I tried the 250gr'rs and they shot well, but I also heard alot of horror stories with thier(both 250 & 300gr) performance. My older brother switched to Barnes TMZ and is giving me all his 300gr SST's (4 boxes). The ultimate test will be the end of May on my bear hunt.
Please offer your oppinion
I too have heard and read about all the stories of the SST's & SW's and I do have my own personal opinion of these bullets. I personally have very little experience with these projectiles - I want to tell you that right off the top. I honestly believe the bad experience stories come from shooting thinned skinned animals (deer) at close ranges, and in reality more deer are shot at 50 yards than 100+ yards. We are shooting the SST's with such velocity it really does not have time to do much except pass thru, unless you hit a major bone. Now that same load will work great on a deer @ 175/200 yards because it has lost enough velocity that it has time to function. I personally lean to the 300 SST's being a better functioning bullet @ close range than the 250.
While your older brother and my best friend really like the Barnes offerings I am stuck on Nosler's. I do not think you can find a better bullet. I shoot the 250 grain Nosler Partition for and the 300 Partition for elk and I will shoot them to a 175 yards without much thought and they work - as I am also positive the Barnes will....
But here is my problem with the SST, Barnes, and yes even the Noslers ($50.00 a box now). I am basically a cheap person and I shoot a lot - I really enjoy shooting - so in fact I can not afford to to shoot those expensive bullets, I shoot alternatives. My main alternative for years has been the offerings from Hornady. I would use my Noslers for hunting and Hornady's for practice. But recently, well it has been a year now at least, I have made a switch. One of the alternatives I found were Speer Gold Dots. I have done a lot of research on these bullets. They are a
bonded bullet and they have been engineered to expand to a point and stop. I shoot both the 250 and 300. The 250 has an extremely deep and wide hollow point - actually remind me of some Barnes X bullets, and the 300 has a small dimple hollow point and a BC of .230. Check these two strings out.... I think they say it all. (although these bullets are now up to about $15.00 a box)
http://www.huntingnet.com/forum/tm.aspx?m=1791957http://www.huntingnet.com/forum/tm.aspx?m=1794250There is one other dark horse I want to tell you about... It might really be an exceptional bullet for anything from varmints to deer class animals. There have been several success stories with this bullet from "yotes" to wild pigs... It is the Hornady 10mm 200 grain XTP in a MMP 40/50cal blue sabot. I shoot this bullet from my inlines with a 110 grains of T7-2f, get remarkable accuracy and velocity (2150 fps) and at that speed it carries a lot of energy. Again I can not afford the Shockwave variety so I shoot the XTP. According to Hornady the perfomance velocity of the 10mm is not even close to the velocity that you are shooting it at from a ML, but the bullets stays together and expands great.
Just sharing some thoughts...
mike