The 3 i have recovered performed just like the pic on thier box,one transverd a Wt deer from front shoulder to hip the other 2 went through both front shoulders of a spike elk and stoped just under the skin on the far side,no missing petals,these were fired at around 3250 fps out of a 7 mag.Im sure the noslers may be every bit as good but the Barnes I have shot performed 100%,the only advantage i could see in the noslers is possibly price,i pay $30 for the barnes in .284 150 gr,if there isnt a huge price difference i wouldnt even try them,the Barnes are tried and proved.