I'm not surprised about the Leupold...I thought that would be one of the two. I have owned a few Leupolds myself and I have never had any problems either. However, the same goes for my Nikons and Elite 4200s, and they have had their share of abuse too.
However, I am a bit surprised about the Simmons. Of the Simmons scopes that I have seen at the gun ranges, I have seen at least one of them have the reticle fall apart, and on another one I have seen (and heard) a shooter next to me cussing up a storm because it wouldn't track at all. That said, I honestly don't remember what model Simmons scope it was, as every manufacturer has different models that have varying quality in each model (and of which is reflected in the price).
I don't want to turn this thread into a topic much different than what it was intended for, but I was just curious to ask, and appreciate your response.
Zachary