I can understand your concern, but consider this - the Clearidge has been nominated as one of the scopes in Outdoor Magazine's Optics of the Year award. As far as comparing them to Nikon Monarchs, Elite 4200s, and Leupold VX-IIIs, the Clearidge glass has 95% light transmission, which is at the same level of these scopes (although the VX-III is a bit higher at 98%).
Further, an additional reason that I make a bold comparison with the Monarchs, Elite 4200s, and VX-IIIs is because, from what I understand, the clearidge line is manufactured at an established plant that does in fact have a proven track record for reliability.
My only dislike about the Clearidge is that it does not have long eye-relief like a Leupold, but, then again, it's eye-relief is very similar to the Elite 4200s.
It is rare for me to recommend a new optics line. In fact, prior to the clearidge, I have never done it. The clearidge is an exception only because I know the people involved and thus a great deal of knowledge behind the scope as well. Buying from theopticzone means that you are essentially buying direct from the factory with no middle man, so that's where your savings are. So I disagree that the clearidge is a "cheaper" scope. If you want clearidge to charge anywhere from 20% to 30% more to dealers above wholesale like Nikon, Bushnell, and Leupold, then would you still consider it a "cheaper" scope?
Like all of you, I don't get anything for endorsing the products I like. As most of you on the bolt-action forums know, I love my Tikkas, but I don't think that Tikka even knows my name, much less pays me for any endorsement. Same holds true for my love for Nikon Monarchs and Elite 4200s. Accordingly, for me to endorse a new product, then that must mean something given that I have done a lot of due dillegence on it. Is it the same as my own hands-on experience over a long period of time? No, I honestly can't, and won't, say that, but I do anticipate that it will be close. So close, in fact, that the next scope that I will buy will in fact be a clearidge, and, as most of you know, I am the type of person who puts his money where this mouth is. BTW, I also intend on buying a Mueller scope in the future too.
Hope this helps.
Zachary