I have several scopes made from several manufacturers. The list of manufacturers and models include the following:
Nightforce NXS
5.5x-22x-56mm Illuminated Mil-Dot
Bushnell Elite 4200
2.5x-10x-50mm Illuminated
Leupold Vari-X III
(2 of) 4.5x-14x-50mm Illuminated
Nikon (both Monarch and Pre-Monarch models)
(1) Pre Monarch 3x-9x-40mm
(2 of) Pre Monarch 3.5x-10x-50mm
(1) Monarch 3.5x-10x-50mm
Burris Black Diamond
(1) 3x-12x-50
(1) 4x-16x-50
I love all of my scopes and they are all great, but if I had to pick my FAVORITE, it would have to be my Nikon Pre-Monarch 3.5x-10x-50mm. Why? It has been on more hunts with me than all of my other scopes so far, and it has NEVER let me down. Bullets always go where they are supposed to, and it has never needed to be re-sighted in.
In fact, one year I accidentally dropped my rifle (with this scope) down the side of a hill (almost as steep as a cliff) after I slipped. It fell and tumbled down about 25 feet or so. No, it was not a straight drop. Rather, it fell to the ground when I fell, and it slid down the hill, bouncing off of the ground, rocks, trees, etc. until it finally got caught up in a bush. I was worried that the scope was going to be dented, but, to my surprise, it wasn't it. Then I thought that the zero was for sure going to be off, but again, it wasn't. How do I know? I didn't have a chance to sight in the rifle to make sure it was bull's eye because camp was 2 miles away and I was in the middle of my hunt. Later that evening, a 6 point buck came within 100 yards of me. I usually take neck shots, but, since I was worried about the zero, I aimed in the middle right behind the shoulder. THE BULLET WENT RIGHT WHERE I AIMED. When I got back to camp, I checked in my zero the next morning, and it was PERFECT!! WOW!!
I also went on to shoot my very first (and several) wild hogs with it, in addition to several deer.
As such, although I give VERY high praise to the Bushnell Elite 4200 as one of the best out there (and for the record, I DO believe that the Bushnell Elite 4200 is better than the Nikon Monarchs), my favorite, for personal reasons, is my Nikon Pre-Monarch 3.5x-10x-50mm.
What is your favorite scope and why?
Zachary