Kywoodwkr,
Thanks for the input but the "good" replacement stock was purchased at a gunshow. The one that was with the gun with my partner got it had the piece chipped out and missing so he bought an aftermarket stock. Which began chipping out.
After I got it I looked over the after market stock as that was what was on the gun and found that the hole was drilled too deep in the butt so the take upscrew bottomed out in the action before it pulled it back into the stock. NOT much, maybe a 1/16th of an inch or so. When the front screw was snugged down there was enough tension to give it the "appearance" of being tight. Each time the action cycled I am sure it moved forward slightly and when fired the action opening hammered it back creating a jackhammer effect.
As for the first original stock I am not sure what happened. Cound have just been a week spot in the wood. It happens sometimes.
I took the good stock, bedded the back of the recoil block, tighten everything up and took her to the range. Shoots good, no problems. Now just gonna take it down to the local Winchester Warranty center to have the firing pin replaced (at no charge) due to a recall by Winchester going back to about 1991.
This is a pre-64 (as per the ser#) looks to have come into the world in 1961. Been shot and hunted with so it isn't pristeen but it has a lot of good years left in her and every year the value of these seems to climb unlike my mutual fund;-)
Again thaks for the input and folks have safe and fun 4th of July..
DonT