Personally, I've always preferred high gloss finishes because in my experience rough matte finishes always rusted easier.
It seems as though the pores in the metal are better sealed when they have a gloss finish applied. When wearing matte finishes, they seem to hold more moisture and rust much easier. Therefore, I've always disliked Remington's SPS and Special Purpose matte finishes.
What are your thoughts and experiences on the subject.