I suspect I will be repeating myself in my response to Sweetwater.
Recently Sweetwater ask the following on August 15th:
“Your opinion solicitated:
1/ replacement model for my Magellan Meridian Gold? One of the 60 series? Or which one?
2/ Onboard GPS (a) stationary or movable between vehicles? (b) Which one?”
I answer question (1/) on the current topic and I will take on question (2/) as part of this topic on the Garmin c550 automotive gps.
I was dreaming about a built-in automotive gps unit for a while. But I am backing off from that unless I win the lotto. The real discouraging event was viewing the dash of a car that had had a built in gps unit. The damage to the vehicle the thieves had done was major. I bet the price tag to repair it is many thousand dollars. Gps units are target by thieves who wonder parking lots, garages, and where ever we may park our vehicle.
I had an opportunity to ride with some friends that have a built in unit. We made a round trip up into Oregon and back. I was seated in the back seat looking at the unit and comparing it with my handheld Garmin 76Cx load with City Navigator. Both screens were duplicating our location, but from a drivers stand point the advantage has to go to the built in automotive gps with it’s much larger screen.
I favor a moveable unit designed for automotive use. It is a different animal then a handheld. I think it would be tough to go wrong with a unit that has a high sensitivity receiver. Tom Tom, Magellan, and Garmin make a number of different models. My son’s Tom Tom goes from his work vehicle, to his fun vehicle, to his wife’s car and the grandson barrows it when he takes a road trip.
A friend’s husband was using a Magellan automotive unit that impressed her enough to buy one for her pickup.
I have no regrets on purchasing the soon to be discontinued Garmin c550. I purchased mine from Tigergps. This unit at one time was the top of the Garmin line, and it shares the features of the up third of the line now. The price is a bargain. I selected a mounting location on the dash that does not block my view. It is against the law in some states to mount a gps on the windshield. Extra dashboard mounts can be purchased in a number of configurations to fit the users need.
The portability comes in handy if you fly to a location and rent a vehicle. My wife is an outstanding navigator, but a portable unit would have been handy when we flew cross-country and rented a vehicle. It is handy when I go from my pickup to the wife’s car, or to the father-in-law’s pickup. For a lot of years my wife has had an AAA map out tracking our progress when we travel strange roads or streets into a city. The 76C and 76Cx with City Navigator has been helpful, and hopefully the c550 we allow her to relax a little more and enjoy the trip. It is nice to plug in an address and have the unit guide you to the location. On some of my trips I like to take a side trip to a local gunshop. In the past I went to the Yellow Pages and found an address, and consulted the AAA map. I might still consult a paper map, but I will plug the address into my gps and let it guide me. On a trip to Southern California the 76Cx did a good job of guiding me to our motel. I needed to fuel-up, and selected the Fuel Services Icon and hit enter, I was given a number of stations starting at the nearest and going out. I selected the brand I prefer, and hit enter and the unit guided me to the station.
When it came time for dinner we decided that we want Mexican food. I went to the Food Icon, hit enter, and we were given a selection of restaurant. One was about half mile from the motel, and we chose to walk. We had spent to many hours driving.
On another emergency trip we traveled with in-laws to close down a gravely ill family members home, and move her belongings North. The 76Cx guided us around town without a hitch. My father-in-law had made arrangements for a U-Haul truck. U-Haul was located across the city, and the gps guide us there. My father-in-law did not have a clue to the location when he made arrangements. Typical of many cities that have been chopped up by freeways, the return route was different then the way we found the business. The gps guided us to the freeway, and our return back to the residence was quick and uncomplicated.
When driving I like the c550 because of the larger screen, and how it displays the City Navigator software over my Garmin 76Cx which has US Topo and City Navigator. The disadvantage when switching vehicles is the lack of additional mounting bases if you are in a “not on the windshield state.” My handheld 76Cx gets good reception inside a vehicle, and when the City Navigator software is selected it does a good job. Two issues come up, it is preferred that a passenger watch the small screen, and navigational directions are given by tone rather then voice directions.
The advantage goes to the handheld because you can carry it with more easily on a hike.
http://www.tigergps.com/garminstreetpilotc550.html