I have the compact model,and I like it very much.I have 5 barrels for mine,and they all shoot as good or better than any of my 9 Handi's that I had. The big difference is less felt recoil,alot less muzzle jump,and more day to day consistant shooting. I shoot some preety hot handloads in my 45 70 and its really fun to shoot.The Handi after about 5 rds is going to start hurting your shoulder.You get a better recoil pad,a very good sling, and a little better shooting gun with the CVA. Budsgunshop has the 45 70 's on sale now for $248 delievered. You might check your combo with them. Digger