I pulled one pan, and started to reshape it as you describe, Tim. I replaced it, and it did seem to fit just a little lower, I guess I was just afraid to beat it too much.
My Dukes are old style 1 1/2's and already have Bridger levers, so Bridger pans sound like a pretty good solution, Mallard.
With that in mind, I'll beat the heck out of the old pans, and either get a good flat fitting pan, or a good excuse to replace with Bridgers.
Thanks,
T-Rex