I too have heard great things about the Marlin XL- series of bolt action rifles but I do not yet own one. So, I can't comment on those. Also, the previous comment about Savage's price advantage disappearing is definitely true. I am amazed how much the current asking prices are for some of their models. With all this being said, 3-4 years ago, I bought my Son-in-Law a SS Savage in 270 Winchester with the accutrigger, a detachable magazine and a synthetic stock. Since my Son-in-Law lives out of town but he has asked me to keep the rifle at my home, I do shoot it every now and then at the range. The only modifications I've done to it are to have the stock shortened to better fit my Son-in-Law and installed a longer and larger tactical bolt handle. I've been thus far quite impressed with this rifle. It is very accurate with many different factory loads, the bolt works smoothly and it feeds bullets from the mag almost effortlessly, and, finally, I like the accutrigger (which probably for me contributes to its accuracy). Yeah, the synthetic stock is flimsy but it has not harmed this rifle's performance yet. So, I guess I'd consider myself a Savage fan. However, if I were to buy a new Savage rifle today, I'd wait for that special circumstance when I'd find the caliber I wanted at a reduced (and to me more reasonable) price.