It wouldn't because the recoil on almost all miniatures is far more violent than recoil on the full size gun. Full size guns do not recoil to a "Tight Breeching" with every shot; in most cases they do this only if double-shotted, or fired for maximum range with the heaviest powder charge used for that purpose or due to unusual sea conditions. Normally the sea-service guns recoil 4 or 5 feet to a horizontal, but not tight breeching. You can see that DD's gun recoiled viciously, just as do ours, two to five times the normal full size recoil, roll back.
Breeching on his gun would probably keep it on the ship's deck, but the muzzle may still touch the deck during roll back or fly-back! The maker does not have to make any errors to have his gun exhibit this phenomenon. Perfectly scaled guns, shot and powder charges reliably exhibit this behavior. It doesn't make any sense, but it's true, nevertheless.
Mike and Tracy