Dang I forgot to post our results:
I decided to go for a Doe. This area is over run with doe vs bucks ratio, so it was the last weekend of either sex whitetail. I shot her at about 20 yards in dark timber using a 530-gr ppbullet over 90.0 gr of FFg. using iron sights. Bullet damage from one of these is nill. Like the old hunters of bison years ago said, "You can eat right up to the hole" :cb2:
My son got his doe the next day from our stand using the 35 Whelen at 9 paces. After caping the doe we discovered that the bullet did so much damage it wasn't funny. Was using a 200-gr JSP Corelock.