John R, I carry a few different guns, depends on my mood. I some times carry a full size 1911, or a Glock 21 SF. Even when I carry a full size gun with me I have my Kal Tec in 380 in my pocket as well. Also in my truck is a gun stashed, so when I am out and about, I always have enough fire power.
I owned a Judge for awhile, it was in my house, next to my bed. I have since replaced it with my Benelli M2 shotgun. Sold the Judge to someone that wanted it more than I did.
Some say I am paranoid, I say I am prepared.
As for the Judge, it was made for a up close gun, and one to get you out of an encounter, it was not designed for a fire fight. If we understand the intent for certain guns, we will all be just fine. Are there better choices, sure there are.