Oh boy,,a Seneca! I never had one, and that they are getting rare, I hessitate to give ya advise. The hammer should line up proper just buy holding lock in the mortise without the screw. Could be someone else before you has messed with it and now your have to figgure out what they did!
I see your new, I'm gonna send ya a PM and that should pop-up a window for ya to read it.,,
perhaps others have some ideas