This was the first case where I had problems with alkaline batteries. They were Duracells (my favorite brand), and the batteries were within their date spec. I use the flashlight pretty regularly. Although it's my emergency flashlight, I also read in bed with it, so they are never in there more than a year or two.
Must be a fluke.
I replaced it with a similar Maglight, but the LED version instead. This is a great flashlight, so long as it is as durable as the old one. Maglight's approach to LED power is a little different than others. They use one big LED. Otherwise it works just like their tungsten lamped flashlights.
That old Maglight was one of my favorite tools.