I saw the reviews, but then you have the last couple:
After reading previous negative ratings I was skeptical but took a chance. The mount was, in my opinion, well made, easy to install, and only MINOR fitting issues on my Rossi. 1 - 15 seconds with a Dremel to take a bit off the main screw (it rubbed the bolt). 2 - Same for rear allen screw so ring would sit flush on the rail (the head stuck up just a bit and hit the bottom of the scope ring). Alignment was great. Best for a short light scope, obviously, but no problems with recoil on .44 Magnum.
And
Found base to work very well with 44 mag Puma. Did take some fitting, nothing major.
So what is real? Guess I will try one and see.
Regarding peep sights; I have used them with mixed results on firearms I do not own. Maybe I will dress the 357 up with the B square and the 44 mag with the peeps and see.
One thing is for sure, the peeps would look better and more natural.