I discourage people from using t5ape and cardboard . It is much more likely to crush than metal .
The correct way is to buy a no-go gauge . They are not that expensive .
If you are not going to do that , go to your favorite auto parts store and buy a cheap feeler gauge , calibrated in thousandths of an inch .
Cut a circle , the diameter of the base of the brass ( with tin snips ) from the .002" , .004" , .006" , etc. . Now do the same as you were with the tape . You can stack them up . Find the measurment / amount it takes to just prevent the bolt from closing 100% .
Now , with the same brass case , check the other guns . ( You are writing this down , aren't you ? )
Compare the results . Now write a nice polite letter to Rossi , asking for help .
In the mean time , for the one , problem , gun only , try seating the bullet long , until the bullet is jammed into the riflings ( not at 100% powder charge ) forcing the base of the brass back , hard against the bolt face . See if that helps ?
Even better , put that gun in the safe untill the issue is resolved .
If Rossie does not help you , one possible repair for a darn good gunsmith , is to either weld up the face of the bolt , adding metal & then machining it back down to give the proper head space ? Or , maybe , I do not know about this , silver solder a shim to the face of the bolt ?
In either case , care must be given as to the heat treating of the steel of the bolt .
God bless
Wyr
Happy New Year