woodstock,
I have posted on your threads elsewhere.
$ 300 is pretty pricey for a 676 with no box, and only the mag cylinder.
I have 8 H&R convertibles.
I have paid over $ 300 for some of them, but, they all had origial box, both cylinders, and excellent condition.
The 4.5" barrel is probably the 2nd hardest to find, behind the 12" model, so that probably helps the value a little.
I would have to talk him down a ways before he sold it to me.
And yes, I still stand behind my statement that lr cylinders are much harder to find than the mag cylinders!
Here's one for you to take a look at, nice piece, decent price!
http://www.gunbroker.com/Auction/ViewItem.aspx?Item=223661105Great revolvers, good luck with this one, or any other you may find.
If I can help, I will share what little knowledge I posess!
Jim
ps I just checked my files. Out of all 5 model 686's I have, which is the new improved 676, with fully adjustable sights, all 1980 pieces. The most I paid is $ 305 for the 12" model.
These were all bought in 2007, and 2008. so the value may have risen a little.
There is a 676 with 5,5" barrel listed on auction right now for $ 299 both cylinders, original box, appears excellent. You see them at this price pretty often.
You should talk him down at least $ 50, or continue loking IMO.
Here's a pic of my model 686 4.5"
Bought in June 2007 $ 225