If by "cratering" you mean primer material is flowing back around the firing pin, it could be caused by an oversize firing pin hole in the breech face, or it could be a timing issue with the pistol it's self. I think you're on the right track by trying different ammo. Some primer materials are softer than others, Federal being one of the softest, and CCI being among the hardest with WW and Rem somewhere in between. If it's not piercing primers, it's likely not a major concern.
Savage