Maybe its just a perception thing, but since Ive gone to water, rather than oil, my stones seem to work better. Anybody seen/ heard anything about this?
FWIW, I found a nice, flat, fine grained old 'shop' stone at a B&S shop that was filthy oily, so I soaked it with Brake Clean and rubbed off the float several times. It cleaned up quickly and well, and I started using it with water; it works great! So I did the same with my Buck stone set I got back in the '70s and have used with Buck Honing Oil since the start. Now with water they are working 'better' too.
I think that maybe the oil makes a nicer finish???, but the water lets the grain structure cut better; ie, faster??? (just like with using wet or dry sandpaper with oil vs water) Ive always heard that you cant start a stone with oil and go to water, but maybe that was a holdover from the days when they didnt have these super penetrating solvents to float the oils out.
Anyway, Ive usually got some spit, if nothing else, to wet a stone to whet an edge rather than waiting and hacking the job.