I've seen kayaking becoming popular in some areas, but can't understand why. Can you explain why it is addicting?
I figure that if I'm out in a 14 foot aluminum boat, I can stand, stretch my legs, walk around in the boat, see better for fishing, carry a guest and a dog, etc. Then there's ease of transport. Just hitch up the trailer and go. And there's propulsion: use oars, a push pole, or an outboard. Draft is shallow enough to handle just a few inches of water, probably less draft than a kayak in fact. Seaworthiness is another factor. I've personally rescued two kayakers in distress because the conditions had changed and their boats had become unsafe. They wind and current were working against them and they were in some real danger. Another time I helped a kayaker right his boat after it had capsized. He was treading water in murky salt water that I had been successfully shark fishing in. I used to have a car top canoe and got tired of the long set up time, dings in my car's finish, and inflexibility, so I sold it.
I will say that I like the concept of the Hobie foot-powered kayaks, but don't like the price. If I had one, I'd have to have a trailer to haul it with, or a pickup truck with a long bed to carry it in. I'm never going back to a car topper.
I live in an area where kayaks are getting popular for fishing, but I still think my aluminum utility boat is the best. To each his own, I guess.