As I mentioned in your other thread, per the encouragement from Gunnut69 I poured some water in bottom of 55 gallon barrel. Hung a 75 watt light in it with the gun parts and covered with an old window pane then put a blanket over the top as insulation..Have now done three guns in it .Works real fast..Rust blued the last one in just 4 cycles over two days...Think you have too small surface area with your water.Try pans or multiple buckets of water....Course I have relatively little experience so better advice may come from somebody else and I would defer to their counsel.