You are as the axe-wielding Gimli in Lord of the Rings; abbreviated in stature with hands that won't palm a basketball? Depending on use, it might be better to have a little extra nitrile than none at all. You could push the extra toward the web (intersection of finger and palm) with the other hand and make it work.
In contrast, I can palm a basketball. On my hands, even XL gloves fit too tightly, don't extend to the web, and are prone to premature tearing.