I think the 180 XTP is best for deer, I shot one with it at 25 yards this past season with my Max and it performed with exellence. I do not think the 258 would have stood up to breaking the onside front leg and still completely penetrating the animal. It should however be nice for coyotes, groundhogs and such. Vance, I get groups that look like yours when using 26 grains of 1680, shooting at 75 yards. It will often put 5 rounds into a cluster like those 3 rounds. That looks like an interesting cast boolit load, any idea of the velocity??? Nice shooten