I've got a Compact in .260 and it isn't so much the recoil, even with 160 gr bullets, as it is the muzzle blast, which out of a 16 1/4" barrel is pretty loud. The velocity loss is pretty substantial as well. I bought this rifle for my wife, and she didn't mind the recoil, but hated the blast. You might consider the Ultra Light in .257 Roberts, 7mm Mauser, or 6.5x55 Mauser if they are still offered. The latter is too light for elk, but very light in recoil, while the other two are reasonable in recoil, but have killed animals up to the size of moose and various species of African antelope over the last 100+ years. Plus the Ultra Light has a 20" barrel, and gives more velocity and less muzzle blast than the Compact.