my brother is asking the identical question and looking for a variable up to 12x or so. We ended pairing choices down to the Bushnell 3200 4x12x40 and the Weaver V16 - 4x16x42. The Weaver is getting the nod because, even though I think 12x is preferred, it has a 42mm objective instead of a 40 and it is FULLY multi-coated, the Bushnell is not. Low light performance was one of the biggest factors in the decision. I told him the 'perfect' scope for his needs was, in my opinion, a Burris Fullfield II 4x12x42. Best price I found was $299. That is the trouble with scopes - if you are on a budget it seems you can get 80% of what you inside your spending limit. To close that gap to 100% it takes bumping up past your budget in monetary steps. Seems these guys know how to dangle fruit just past your outstretched finger tips. For example, I found the Bushnell for $249, the V16 for something like $270. I mentioned the Burris because it was still under $300 - once you leap past the $300 mark a lot of choices open up - and many seem,more or less, EXACTLY what you want. I don't want to come across as knocking the 3200's because folks do swear by them. Just telling you how our mnids dissected the exact same question you have.