I bought the 26" barrelled 870 because I thought the 28" was a little unwieldily. It may be because I'm pretty short. I used to use a 20ga 1100 for grouse hunting with what I think is a 28" barrel. It could be a real pain while charging through the thick stuff. The longer barrel does swing a little nicer, but for the type of hunting I do, the extra maneuverability of the 26 incher is the way to go.