I have been using BSA Scopes for 4 years now on my Silhouette guns. The first one I got was a 3-12 BSA Contender. It lasted 2 years, then the horizontal adjustment would not repeat. I had a Lupold vx1 3-9 that I put on while BSA sent me another scope. I was not happy with that one so they sent me TWO Platinum 6-24 scopes to replace it. I kept the best one and sold the other one to a guy who wanted it on a hunting rifle. I won 2ed AAA with that scope in our state match that year. My score was 52 out of 60. I was in a shoot off with another guy who had the same BSA Scope on his gun. The Next year I got 1st AAA in the state match with the same scope. That scope lost the horizontal adjustment this winter and is now on its way to BSA and they will send me some new ones to try.
I have sold the Lupold, I just don't like it as good as I do the BSA. I have a Bushnell ScopeSmith 6-20 that I am using as a replacement right now but I can't get as good of groups, from a bench, that I have gotten with the BSAs.
Since I have been using the BSA scopes I have been shooting AAA scores, 30 to 35 out of 40, very consistently. I have shot one 39 out of 40 with a BSA Scope, last summer.
Yes, you do get what you pay for, If you pay $300 for a lupold you may be satisified and never have to replace it but I paid $89 for my first BSA and the real cost is sending each one back and getting it replaced. BSA has never questioned the reasons that I send the scopes back and they are always willing to go the extra mile to please me.
Sixgun