Interesting points about loading and setting the cylinder back to the hand...
The drag mark I'm starting to see it heavier just after the knotch in the cylinder and quickly trails off. To check if it was timing/indexing, I smoked the cylinder with a candle-(blackened it). I worked the action, slow and fast, using a 10X ring, I could only make out a little rub mark after a couple of the notches and it was just on the soot from the candle.
What I couldn't check was how it worked when all fouled up with BP, and that may just be the issue. These ASM conversions foul the cylinder pin very quickly, by some very carefull work I've managed to get it to go 30 shots with no real stiffness in the cylinder, after that it starts to get stiff and it's not usable at 40shots. So, until recently, most of my shooting has been smokeless and no lines, now that I'm shooting all BP loads, it's starting.
I'm pretty sure that the fouling build up between the pin and the cylinder is changing the way it spins-(geometry) just enough for that bolt to drag a little as it comes out of the cylinder. Real hard to explain but once I get it real dirty I'm gonna repeat my experiment with the candle. It all kind of fits, the gun has been well maintained, shot a bunch with no trouble, until I started using all BP. BTW: I didn't shoot alot of BP befor because when I started it wouldn't go 5 shots without stiffening up..
Did any of that make sense? :-)
Thanks
1860