I considered it and I really wanted a 35 Whelen, but the 357mag has a 1:18¾" twist rate, 35 Whelen has 1:16" or faster, I didn't do it cuz the reason for the Whelen was to shoot 250gr-275gr or bigger bullets at Whelen velocities. And with H&R bores tendancy to be on the big side of bore specs, I think that would be not be the best combination. Ultimately my gunsmith recommended against it after I discussed it with him, so I'm glad I was hesitant. If you want to shoot lighter bullets in it, it would work fine, but it's not likely to work for the longer, heavier bullets. The barrel length is the other catch, a 24-26" Whelen barrel makes a lot more sense to me than a 22". Some folks here think the 1:18¾" twist rate will work fine for the heavier bullets.....my gunsmith doesn't agree and I trust his experience since it's his business to know such things. :wink: