Mike103,
I lived and hunted in upsate NY for 20 years, 1978-1998. Hunted in the shotgun hunting area near the Finger Lakes and then up in the foothills of the Adirondacks with rifle. I would suppose you are in the Catskill area where rifle is allowed? Have driven through the area headed to southern New England, but never walked the brush there.
I used to hunt with a fellow in upstate NY who bought a Remington 7600 in .35 Whelen the minute they hit the shelves (late 80s I think it was). He traded in his 760 in 06 and never looked back. He was just a hunter, not being into target shooting and reloading. For the better sectional density he stayed with the 250 grain factory loads on my advice. Well, he has quite a nice tract of private land, and that rifle has never failed him. Having hunted the land with him when I lived in NY, I can almost guarantee he has probably never shot over 75 or so yards. His kills when I was with him probably averaged around 30-40 yards. All his kills have been one shot, most dropping at the hit, a traditional he has kept going over the last 8 seasons since I hunted with him. I think you can't go wrong with the .35 Whelen and am always confounded at why the cartridge was a commercial failure.