Values are subjective. If you are a dealer and have to worry about making a profit, then that is one thing. But if you are a hobbyist, like most of us, the value to each will be different, depending on how much you want it for your personel use.
I've seen Skikaris sell between 200 and 250 several times. To me, this is a fair price for one in good condition. Especally when you consider the fact that you are getting a cut-rifled barrel. Even thought i have a BC, if I lost my Shikari I'd start looking for a replacement right away. When I head out shooting for fun or hunting, I alway seem to grab the Shikari. I like it's style, balance and low hammer. It may shoot only "Springfield" loads, but they do very well on deer. And I enjoy those loads more then the hot ones.
I'm even toying with the idea of cutting my BC back to 24 inches. I find the long tube very un-handy when hunting. Since I use smokeless loads, I do not need the long tube for ballistics, and since I scope everything now, i do not need the extended sight radius.
Now, if I could just find another Shikari stock set.
Wally