The Constitution gives everyone the right to an arm, but everyone does not have the common sence to own one. This guy is the reason the Liberals are winning. If the brother-in-law had killed the idiot, he probably would have done the world a favor, but would have had to have lived with the fact for the rest of his life. I really don't give a rat's ass what the law says, you have to prove self defence, and depending on where you live, to what degree your live was being threatened. Rediculious!! I'm glad that everyone was unhurt. They will catch the guy, and he'll get a $100 plus court cost fine and 6 months probation unless he pleads guilty to a lesser charge. I guess under the circumstances they did the right thing, except calling you before calling the police. Personally, I'd have been hard pressed not to return fire. Course, my neighbor is in jail now for shooting his wife in the face with a 357. I may have a different mindset.