I think many of the hunting shows give a poor impression to the non-hunter. I just started hunting again about 2 years ago, after an almost 30 years hiatus.
I began watching the stuff on OLN and the Outdoor Channel, the biggest flaw seems to be they preach to the choir as it where. Most people do not hunt or use firearms and bows regularly, thus when they show 10 minutes of a guy, who often sounds inarticulate, sitting in a stand over a food plot, or a bear bait site the presentation comes of rather lame. Especially after the guy poses with the animal and tells of how thrilled he is, and it is a dream come true.
Very little time, if any, is spent explaining the need for wildlife management, to accommodate the developmental spread. I feel they would be better served if they spent some time reminding non-hunters, how many deer car collisions there are, or emphasis shrinking habitat due to urban development and the consequences of over animal population, and thus a need for culling.
Truth is few non-hunters will ever become hunters, but they can become allies if they see a benefit from the activities of hunters, instead of approaching it, as an us (hunters), against them (non-hunters).
Truth is there will always be some that are opposed to wildlife management in any form but they are a minority, as few will commit suicide so the animals can inherit the earth, but not explaining the benefits of hunting to a large percentage of people who do not understand how it directly benefits their interests, is in my opinion is a mistake.
As to canned hunts or shooting animals in small pens, I think it is lame. Since I started hunting again, I have found the time in the outdoors to be the reward, the meat is an added bonus. If hunting shows were presented in this light I think, the majority (non-hunters) would find it less objectionable and be less inclined to approve the growing restrictions against hunting.
Hunters today serve many functions, not only do we provide wildlife management, so as to accommodate urban growth, we also provide for maintenance of wildlife areas and are an economic source, that benefits both non-hunters and hunters alike It is a mistake not to emphasis and remind those who will never hunt, of these contributions.
Life is no joke but funny things happen
jon