I have a pair of each. I bought the Past first, and was still whacking my gun hand middle finger. I got a set of Uncle Mike's and I'm very happy with them. In my case, I bought size large, even though I normally wear a size 9 1/2 glove. If they are too tight, they become restrictive in your grip and are hard to remove. I don't shoot anything with more recoil than a .357 magnum without gloves anymore. I did some damage to my hand shooting hard kickers when I was young and foolish, and have bone chips floating around in my knuckles. I put around 15,000 rounds through my first Ruger SBH, and that square backed trigger guard got me.