Well, I have never had the Wild West, but I thought the XS was outragously high. I bought 3 of their front sights and one rear for my 1895cb 4570. Didn't have enough ajustment in it. I eventually ordered a Lyman Receiver sight and put on it. Lyman said none of their sights fit a Marlin 1895cb, but I guess they aren't gunsmiths. I ordered two for a Model 94 Winchester. I put one on my Model 92 clone, and one on my 1895 marlin cowboy. Works like penicillin used to.