Definately get the 45-70!!! It is a much more versital caliber, fun, and will do anything you ask of it in North America. Besides, it's just so much fun to slide one of those long cartridges into the chamber! I have the 'BC' and I love it! I didn't think I would like the sights either as I have scopes on everything now days (old eyes), but I find I can group under 2" at 100 yards from the bench with those sights. I also thought of cutting about 4" off the barrel and using it with a scope but I like it so much that way it is, i don't want to change anything! I guess I'll just have to buy another one to do that with. (any excuse for another gun, right?) I hope you have as much fun with yours as I have with mine. 44 Man