I want to make sure I understand, you say that the weight doesn't bother you that much. You must be sure about this before you decide, since this is the main "con" of the bull barrel. What is your own strenght & endurance level? I can tell you that most of my hunting rifles have heavy barrels & it is not a problem for me. I go out West & carry them all day, but everything is relative, for one thing I am a pretty good sized feller, I grew up on a farm & played ball & had lifted weights for twenty years or so & this would help. So what is heavy for one person is not for another, you gotta love these gun writers who tell us EXACTLY what a gun should weigh whether your Goldie Haun or Hulk Hogan. You should borrow a bull barreled gun from a friend or a gun shop & on your day off carry it around / go walking for a long time & see. If you can't find anyone to help you with this, you may need to move to an area that has serious shooters.
Another thing that I have done is I have bought a sling that drapes over my shoulder much like you would carry a M60 & the rifle hangs in front of you. It is made out of stretch rubber with a cloth cover. I can throw up the rifle quickly for an up close offhand shot or go prone quick to use my bi-pod. This makes the gun very little different than carrying a light rifle
with a conventional sling, how bout them apples? As I have told Killdeer
in another thread, as soon as I can find the company that makes this sling,
I will post it.
If you determine that the weight is not an issue, as others have allready said, buy it!!!
Alot of what has been said in previous posts is correct but some things were overlooked. Shooting a group from a bench is not the issue at all, as
I rarely get to take a bench on an Elk hunt. Try holding a light rifle steady in a hard wind (like out West, for example) versus a heavy barrel & the heavy kicks butt. When you shoot from a pack, bi pod, you name it the heavy is much more steady & that means the difference between hit & miss. At the bench, you can use the right kind of rest & bags to make a light or heavy rifle steady, but in field conditions you will be much more accurate with a heavy barrel.
I use light rifles when I am in the thick stuff sometimes or sometimes when I am sitting about 30' up in one of my climbers, but when I know the shots could be tough, I know what I will have.
I see you live in the mountains of PA. I know there are shooters in that part of the Country that will let you test a heavy a little.