I would definitely call Ruger, I bet they will make it right, their customer service is great. I have two single sixs both 5.5 one blue, one stainless both shoot into about 1.5 inches with iron sights with either good Long Rifle or Magnum. I don't have a scope on either so I don't know what they are truly capable of. I would think the Hunter should be much better. I almost traded my stainless for a hunter but decided I liked the 5.5 better as I thought it would be handier, sounds like I made a good decision, if yours is representative, let us know how this turns out.